Analysis of Toolbox Characteristics

Today I will analyse a selection of 7 currently used toolboxes, and try to see which elements I would like to keep, and which are missing or need to be improved for my project, the Inclusive Design toolbox.

To analyse how the different toolboxes would compare, I used an associative card sorting technique. Each toolbox is represented by a pink post-it, with its features attached in smaller post-its. On a big sheet, I connected similar features by lines.

rosettes

IMG_1111

Then, I copied the common elements, and some elements that I felt were unique or desirable for my toolbox, to new post-its. I arranged these arrow-shaped tabs so that little clusters of related concepts would form, this way there were 6 main concepts left. I see these 6 aspects and their sub-chapters as a wishlist for the toolbox I am developing:

  • Overview (images, few methods)
  • Credibility (TNO, literature)
  • General guidelines (ethics, recruiting participants, checklists)
  • Step-by-step (filtering, symbols, short routing)
  • Examples (personas, best practices)
  • IT-specific (Agile, Scrum, UX)

IMG_1112

I compared the existing methods to this wish list, and found that in only three toolboxes, all the desired aspects of a toolbox are covered. Perhaps I can use the strengths of these toolboxes to get inspired for my own project:

  • Designing With People: Credibility, Examples, Guidelines, Overview
  • HCD Connect: Overview, Step-by-step
  • Verify: IT specific

If nothing else, I can use the framework developed here, to compare other toolboxes in the future.

IMG_1113

IMG_1115

Check out the Depository of Existing Design Toolboxes!

Advertisements

Please tell me what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s